|
|
|
Quibbles with the methodology used by Central Connecticut State University to rate the nation's most (and least) literate cities. Go to the post to learn what means...
The trouble with the "Most Literate Cities" list is the overreliance on per capita measurements, which inevitably creates a bias in favor of smaller cities, and doesn't accurately reflect what living in a particular city means for a reader. Say City A has a population of 200,000 and three bookstores for every 10,000 population and City B has a population of a million and one bookstore for every 10,000. The reader in City A has access to 60 bookstores and the individual reader in City B has access to 100 bookstores. Or take newspapers. The Seattle Times reaches a higher per capita number of readers in its city than the Los Angeles Times. Does the Seattle Times reader have a better newspaper to read? No, because even with the per capita handicap the Los Angeles Times has four times the circulation and many more advertisers to draw on, so its resources are far greater. The most impressive performer in these surveys is probably San Francisco, which I believe it is the highest population city to compete successfully on a per capita basis.
It is certainly true that Los Angeles has a literacy problem that Seattle doesn't have, but calling that city "more literate" is not a particularly useful way of framing it. It's not as if Seattle had been faced with the task of educating tens of thousands of desperately poor and often non-English speaking people and succeeded. If Los Angeles ever does succeed at this it will have far more to teach Seattle about literacy than vice-versa.
Robert Fiore
Century City
I could just scream. Let's not send our children to Central Connecticut State University for their social-science education. (I kinda think that Dr. John W. Miller doesn't deserve his $214,274 annual salary.)
Maybe these guys cut their teeth formulating the twelfth Soviet Five Year Plan.
What do I mean? Well, for starters, omitted from the list of categories (see left column) are... oh let's see... "book publishers " and "universities"...
1. But maybe I'm being too parochial. Let's go with what they have. Take a look at "Internet Resources" -- when you read the first page, it seems sensible enough:
Internet resourcesInternet resources were indexed as four variables. These numbers were then divided by the city population in order to calculate ratios of internet resources available to the population.
Number of library Internet connection per 10,000 library service population
Number of commercial and public wireless Internet access points per capita
Number of Internet book orders per capita
Percentage of adult population that has read newspaper on Internet
3. But what about the fine print, under "Methodology"?
Internet DataFigures for the Internet accessibility database were obtained from Intel Corporation's 3rd Annual "Most Unwired Cities" survey, which ranks the top 100 U.S. cities and regions for the greatest wireless Internet accessibility. Figures for the "number of internet terminals at public libraries" were obtained from the Fiscal Year 2004 Public Libraries Survey from the National Center for Education Statistics website. Figures for "read a newspaper online" and "purchased a book online" were obtained from Scarborough Research's August 2004-September 2005 USA+2005 Release. Cities were ranked according to the index figures provided by Scarborough. Please note that Scarborough did not have data for the following cities: Long Beach, CA; Mesa, AZ; Plano, TX; Corpus Christi, TX; Bakersfield, CA; Aurora, CO; Arlington, TX; Colorado Springs, CO; New Britain, CT; Anaheim, CA; New Orleans, LA; Omaha, NE; Riverside, CA; Anchorage, AK; Santa Ana, CA; and Newark, NJ. Hence, all of those cities were ranked last.
4. Oh, I see... the survey didn't have data for all the cities I named a minute ago (Anaheim, Bakersfield, Santa Ana, Long Beach, Riverside), so the surveyors just ranked them dead last. Why not? It serves those damn places right for being inconvenient.
P.S. Next up from Central Connecticut State University: "Places Around the World with the Best Weather" -- I hear that Tahiti and Honolulu tie for last, with an average temperature of 0 degrees Kelvin.
Scott McAuley
Angel City Press
Santa Monica
Effective business articles that will improve your business.
Understanding the difference between accidents and incidents is essential for effective risk assessments. Both terms are often used interchangeably, but in the context of workplace safety, they have distinct meanings … Read More
Managing construction projects effectively requires not only skilled labor and quality materials but also the right equipment for the job. For contractors, balancing the need for specialized heavy machinery with … Read More
Choosing the right hosting company and plan is crucial to ensuring your website’s performance, scalability, and cost-effectiveness. With so many hosting options available, it can be overwhelming to know which … Read More
The health and wellness markets are part of a rapidly expanding segment of the global business economy. People are taking a proactive approach to improving their general quality of life, … Read More
Job interviews can be nerve wracking, yet exciting experiences. This is your opportunity to take the next step of your career, but at the same time, you probably have a … Read More
Investing in real estate doesn’t always mean amassing a portfolio of traditional properties like single-family rentals. For some, becoming a landlord may not be their dream. Nevertheless, would-be investors want … Read More
In the modern world where your online footprint matters most, enhancing your business website’s SEO is not just beneficial; it’s essential. With millions of searches conducted every day, your online … Read More
While credit cards are undeniably convenient for everyday purchases, using them to fund your bank account can be a financially precarious move. The high fees and potential credit score implications … Read More
All-on-4 denture implants have revolutionized dental restoration, offering a transformative solution for individuals with missing teeth or ill-fitting dentures. This innovative approach provides a stable and permanent solution by securing … Read More
Nobody likes seeing those flashing red and blue lights in your rearview mirror? Getting a speeding ticket can be frustrating and costly, but don’t lose hope we have some helpful … Read More
