Books

Author's quake prediction for San Andreas debunked

Author Simon Winchester has written some nice books, including about earthquakes and other geological phenomena, but quake scientists say he's a little shaky in his latest stab at seismology. After the 9.0 Japan quake, Winchester took to Newsweek to posit that the quake raised the likelihood of a big San Andreas quake, mostly because it sits on the other side of the tectonic plate that shifted under the sea off Japan. Balderdash, say all the quake experts contacted by LiveScience.com.

"There is no evidence for a connection between all of the Pacific Rim earthquakes," Nathan Bangs, a geophysicist who studies tectonic processes at the University of Texas Institute for Geophysics, told Life's Little Mysteries. "I don't know what the basis is for the statements and implications in the Newsweek article, but there is no evidence that there is a link."

U.S. Geological Survey earthquake geologist David Schwartz, who heads the San Francisco Bay Area Earthquake Hazards Project, concurred. "Simon Winchester is a popular science writer, not a scientist," Schwartz said. "I'm not saying we won't have an earthquake here in California at some point in the future, but there really is no physical connection between these earthquakes."

Related but unconnected: Rebecca Solnit, author of "A Paradise Built in Hell: The Extraordinary Communities That Arise in Disaster," writes for Zocalo: "We can’t stop the earth from shaking. What we can do is stop rewarding journalism that spreads misinformation or hysteria, stop tolerating government responses that needlessly fracture communities, and start preparing with drills and gear."


More by Kevin Roderick:
Gustavo Arellano, many others join LA Times staff
Power out Monday across Malibu
Put Jamal Khashoggi Square outside the Saudi consulate on Sawtelle
Here's who the LA Times has newly hired*
LA Observed Notes: Clippers hire big-time writer, unfunny Emmys, editor memo at the Times and more
Recent Books stories on LA Observed:
Kwame Anthony Appiah
Harlan Ellison, dangerous visionary
LA Observed Notes: Gaza to El Segundo, Kilauea to Burbank
Backstage at the Huntington
Caravan Books closed
Caravan Book Store closing
Barnes & Noble closes in Santa Monica
Pop Sixties


 

LA Observed on Twitter