Environment

Mono Lake bacteria may be nothing special

Did this month's revelations of an arsenic-eating microbe in the mud at Mono Lake really upend our basic understanding of how life works? Not so much, a growing chorus of scientists is saying. Karen Kaplan and Eryn Brown in the LAT:

News reports were dewy-eyed with wonderment over the study, which challenged conventional notions of what life on Earth — or elsewhere — could look like. Then, in short measure, came the scientific trash talk.

"Flim-flam." "Naive." "Fraudulent."

An embarrassing PR gaffe? Mediocre science that got undue attention because the buildup was too sexy to resist? A case of the peer-review process gone horribly wrong?

All played a role. But mostly, the wrangling is just a turbo-charged version of the kind of debate researchers have engaged in for centuries.


More by Kevin Roderick:
Standing up to Harvey Weinstein
The Media
LA Times gets a top editor with nothing but questions
LA Observed Notes: Harvey Weinstein stripped bare
LA Observed Notes: Photos of the homeless, photos that found homes
Recent Environment stories on LA Observed:
Cubs P-57 and P-58 have died in the Santa Monicas
Palm weeds of Santa Susana
New male lions: Meet P-55 and P-56
Desert flowers and fancy at Anza-Borrego
P-51 found dead on freeway where mother and other cub died
Cub P-52 killed on same freeway as mother lion
Time for some weather geeking
P-39 hit and killed crossing freeway


 

LA Observed on Twitter